Sergei A. Belov
-
Jurisprudence of constitutional values: origin, criticism and defense against itMoscow University Bulletin. Series 11. Law. 2024. 2. p.3-31read more316
-
Values approach to the substance and interpretation of constitution originates from Weimar Germany and after World War II was adopted and applied by the Federal Constitutional Court (Bundesverfassungsgericht) soon after it’s establishing. Declaring the constitution as “objective order of values” inspired legal scholars in Germany and abroad to develop the value theory of law and borrowed by courts of Brazil, South Africa, Israel, Venezuela and Russia. At the same time jurisprudence of values became an object of sharp critics, manifested in a book published in Germany in 1960 by Carl Schmitt — Tyranny of values and later developed by other authors. Opposing their arguments, author defenses the values method of constitutional interpretation and describes the features and specificity of thinking about constitution as a system of values. Author reasons that values are not aggressive, do not pretend to dominate over norms and principles and are not subjective. The author’s position supports the idea that values choice is not rational, while states that this does not impede to keep law certain and predictable — if the values, found by courts behind the legal norms and principles and applies in concrete cases, will be explicitly defined and consequently and non-contradictorily realized in judicial practice.
Keywords: constitutional interpretation, constitutional values, legal values, tyranny of values, objective order of values, Lūth case
-
-
Scientific school of commercial law at Moscow University: AchievementsMoscow University Bulletin. Series 11. Law. 2024. 6. p.87-94read more41
-
The article examines the history of the development of the science of commercial law at the Lomonosov Moscow State University. The authors, based on the study of a number of normative sources and works of Russian legal scholars such as Leshkov V. N., Nersesov N. O., Gusakov A. G., Nefedyev N. A., Shershenevich G. F., Krasnokutsky V. A., comprehend the epistemology of modern commercial law and the basic principles of its construction. In the article, the authors note the continuity of research in the field of commercial law in the works of Agarkov M. M., Genkin D. M., Lunts L. A., Peretersky I. S., Goykhbarg A. G., Yaichkov K. K. and many other famous scientists. A special role in the article is given to the professor and scientific director of the Department of Commercial Law Boris Ivanovich Puginsky, who not only revived the teaching of commercial law within the walls of Moscow University, but also laid the doctrinal and methodological basis of the modern science of commercialism — the science of commercial (trade) law. Today, the Department of Commercial Law and the Fundamentals of Jurisprudence is represented by a large scientific heritage in the form of publications of monographs, textbooks and scientific articles and a team of highly professional teachers promoting the ideas of commercial law in the student community.
Keywords: commercial law, trade law, Puginsky B. I., civil law tools, teaching law students, Moscow University.
-